The Hunt for Dark Breakfast – Can we derive breakfasts we have never observed?
This whimsical post treats breakfast as a rigorous scientific inquiry, mapping milk, egg, and flour ratios onto a "Breakfast Simplex" to discover unobserved "dark breakfasts." It's popular on HN for its creative application of complex mathematical and scientific language to a mundane, relatable topic, blending humor with an unexpected intellectual depth. The article playfully invites readers to join the hunt for the forbidden, potentially world-ending, breakfast combinations.
The Lowdown
The author recounts a "hypoxia-addled" flash of insight: breakfast can be understood as a vector space defined by the ratios of milk, eggs, and flour. This realization led to a humorous yet earnest quest to map all known breakfasts within this "manifold" and identify the "Dark Breakfast Abyss" – regions where no breakfast currently exists.
- The journey began by mapping familiar breakfasts like pancakes, crepes, and scrambled eggs, revealing distinct clusters and a significant gap.
- Extensive research, including consulting "friendly ghosts" (Gemini AI) and "ancient tomes" (Wikipedia), was conducted to fill the map with international variants like kaiserschmarrn and dan bing, but the abyss remained.
- Three primary clusters emerged: the chaotic "Pancake Local Group," the versatile "Baked Good Quadrant," and the "Egg Singularity and Custard Accretion Disk."
- A crucial clue was found in an obscure IHOP document revealing their omelettes contain pancake batter, which, when plotted, suggested the abyss might not be entirely empty after all.
- The author warns that IHOP is playing a dangerous game, potentially risking the creation of the "Forbidden Breakfast" that could end the world, humorously referencing the Waffle House Index.
- For intrepid "breakfast scholars," the author provides data, code, and a recipe for "Dark Breakfast" (milk, eggs, flour) with the ominous instruction: "Instructions: Unknown."
Concluding with a H.P. Lovecraft quote, the piece playfully frames culinary exploration as a perilous dive into forbidden knowledge, blending pseudo-scientific rigor with a delightful sense of absurdism.
The Gossip
Dimensional Delights
Commenters enthusiastically expand on the breakfast simplex, suggesting additional dimensions beyond milk, eggs, and flour, such as bacon, sausage, potatoes, or vegetables, to create a more comprehensive "latent space" for breakfast items. There's also good-natured critique regarding the mathematical projection of a 3D space into a 2D triangle.
Culinary Conjectures
Many users attempt to identify existing dishes or propose new combinations that might occupy the "Dark Breakfast Abyss" or closely resemble the author's theoretical forbidden breakfast. Suggestions range from highly eggy crepes to eggs with white gravy, or even a roux-based hollandaise, sparking a playful quest to name and locate the unobserved.
Edibility Enigmas
A core discussion revolves around the practical culinary reasons why the "Dark Breakfast Abyss" might be empty. Commenters posit that such combinations simply don't cook well or result in unpalatable textures, like a "gummy mess" for an overly-battered omelette. The consensus leans towards culinary evolution having naturally selected against these undesirable ratios, explaining their absence.