HN
Today

Quad9 Is Leaving France: Why DNS Resolvers Are the Wrong Place to Fight Piracy

Quad9, a privacy-focused DNS resolver, is pulling out of France after being fined for refusing to block pirate sports streaming sites. This move spotlights the escalating conflict between copyright enforcement and internet infrastructure, forcing a non-profit security service to flee rather than compromise its principles. Hacker News is abuzz with concerns over internet censorship, the futility of DNS blocking, and the dangerous precedents being set for digital freedom and security across Europe.

126
Score
16
Comments
#1
Highest Rank
5h
on Front Page
First Seen
Nov 18, 2:00 PM
Last Seen
Nov 18, 6:00 PM
Rank Over Time
11345

The Lowdown

Quad9, the Swiss non-profit behind the secure, privacy-preserving 9.9.9.9 DNS resolver, is ceasing operations in France. This drastic measure comes after a Parisian court fined Quad9 for its refusal to block a list of pirate sports-streaming domains on behalf of beIN Sports, with around 20 similar cases still pending. Quad9's departure highlights a critical showdown between copyright holders, national courts, and the fundamental architecture of the internet.

Here are the key takeaways from the situation:

  • Quad9's Mission: As a non-profit, Quad9 focuses on blocking malware and phishing domains while maintaining strict user privacy, operating from Switzerland to leverage its strong privacy laws.
  • French Legal Landscape: France's Article L.333-10 allows rights holders to obtain 'dynamic' blocking orders against 'any person able to help stop the infringement,' broadening the net to include DNS resolvers.
  • Escalating Pressure: The legal targeting has expanded from ISPs to public DNS resolvers, search engines, VPNs, and CDNs, with Quad9 being fined €1,000/day for non-compliance.
  • Inability to Comply: Quad9 cannot simply comply due to three core issues: 1) Global blocking would impose French law worldwide; 2) Geo-blocking is technically unreliable, legally problematic, and failed in a prior German case; 3) Protracted legal battles are financially unsustainable for a non-profit.
  • Ineffectiveness of DNS Blocking: The article argues that DNS blocking doesn't remove content, is easily bypassed (with 20% of French users already using alternative DNS), is blunt (overblocks), opaque (no error message), and causes significant collateral damage (e.g., Google Drive blackouts in Italy).
  • Consequences for France: Driving Quad9 out harms French users by removing a vital malware filter, risks silently breaking critical infrastructure, reduces resolver choice (favoring large corporations), and undermines France's own digital sovereignty goals.
  • Wider European Trend: Similar pressures are emerging in Belgium, Italy, and Spain, although Germany has rejected resolver blocking. The EU is reportedly watching France's approach as a potential model.

Ultimately, Quad9's withdrawal from France serves as a stark warning. It underscores how attempts to combat piracy through DNS-level censorship can erode internet security, privacy, and open access, pushing essential non-profit services out of critical regions.

The Gossip

Automated Authorship Accusations

Several commenters quickly identified the article as AI-written, finding it ironic given the story's context where Quad9's CTO requested a 'well-reasoned statement.' The article's author later confirmed it was indeed an AI summary, jokingly referring to 'Al Smith' as their AI agent.

DNS Debacles and Dubious Decisions

The discussion widely questioned the sanity and effectiveness of using DNS resolvers to combat piracy. Many found it 'insane' that legal frameworks could force DNS blocking, arguing that 'every place is the wrong place to fight piracy' due to the ease of bypassing such measures. Others noted that the EU is generally a highly regulated environment, making such strong legal actions less surprising.

Political Predation, Not Policy Progress

A strong undercurrent of cynicism emerged regarding the motivations of policymakers. Commenters argued that judges and lawmakers aren't acting out of ignorance about technology but are driven by money and vested interests. The sentiment was that appeals to reason or 'correct' technical approaches are futile against those who have power and are operating perfectly according to their own agenda.

Self-Sovereign Solutions

Some users suggested technical workarounds to such blocking, such as running a self-hosted recursive DNS resolver. These comments implicitly highlight the futility of broad DNS blocking measures, as technically savvy users can easily circumvent them, leaving only less informed users impacted.